Flash News

Why Jesus not the Ideal for Bishops to follow?; Where is Vivekananda’s India?

September 18, 2018 , Dr. James Kottoor

Why Jesus banner-1

By T J S George in New Indian Express, Published: 16th September 2018

Vivekananda’s short address in Chicago is still remembered, 125 years later, as a historic marker in the march of ideas.

Note: When Vivekananda spoke 125 years ago in Chicago he was only 30 years old, the age when Jesus started his public ministry and ended (rather forced to end) after 3 years. Compare it to the Leaders of Churches all over the world.


It is the youth in their thirties, who have the get-up-and-go, the physical and mental stamina to take risks, who can be bold to blaze new trails, and walk from front lines to lead tirelessly, fearlessly, come what may!

Compare it to leaders in the church who are in the Sannyasa years and forced to retire at 75. This year the Catholic Church is celebrating the Youth of the Church, although they don’t trust the youth and don’t generally appoint anyone in their thirties as Bishops. During the “Church in India Seminar” long ago I recall my revered and beloved Cardinal Parecattil walking in the opposite direction. He stoped, smiled at me very affectionately and said: “You are too young to be the editor of the New Leader!”

In the New Leader
I took it as a compliment by smiling back, because I was a very strong of his Indianisation crusade and he knew it. I was also the first one to interview him after becoming a cardinal. On his way back to Kerala he stopped in Chennai(Madras) and staid in the Archbiishop’s house for the night to pay homage at St.Thomas’ tomb. That night I interviewed him and published it in the New Leader as its editor.

James photoThe Cardinal was just expressing the mindset of the times, which has not changed one bit even today, although we still continue proudly to speak of “Brhmacharia, Grahasta, Vanaprsta, Sannyasa” as the highly recommendable four stages of life according to Hindu Sastras.

Lead, follow or get out
In what stage of life are most of our bishops: Vanaprasta or Sanyasa? “Lead, follow or get out of the way as a nuisance!” is what a wise adage suggests. Comparing Jesus’ ministry to those of our bishops, this scribe wrote in New Leader times, that “the office a bishop should be limited to just three years, since all agree, even bishops, that the only honest man in the world could not survive more than three years in public ministry! So shouldn’t Bishops who call themselves other Christ and close followers imitate his example?”

Will the Churches ever dare to appoint today young bishops with real “get-up-and-go coupled with vision, conviction and ideals” or only those whose “get-up-and go got up and went” long ago and have become unproductive and harmless physically in particular, to prevent embarrassing situations like Jalandar, but still capable of saying; “Yes my Boss!” to those above and will never talk back?

Avoid Jesus’ Mistakes!
If only Jesus had kept his ‘blessed mouth’ shut and stayed as “Sweet Jesus meek and mild” he surely would have lived a thousand years. The terrible mistake he did was he “opened his loud mouth” and worse he also became “bitter Jesus rough, rude and wild” in taking up the whip to chase out the thieves or ‘rascals’ in the temple.

TJS George in his article below makes telling comparisons between Bishop Mulakkal of Jalandar and India’s present political leaders. You decide where, why and how Jesus ceased to be a MODEL LEADER for our bishops to imitate and follow. For me he is still the ideal leader to follow. james kottoor, editor ccv.

Please read below TJS George’s article In the New Indian Express

Here is the noblest summing up of civilisational values by an Indian:

pngI am proud to belong to a religion which has taught the world both tolerance and universal acceptance. We believe not only in universal toleration, but we accept all religions as true. I am proud to belong to a nation which has sheltered the persecuted and the refugees of all religions and all nations of the earth… Sectarianism, bigotry and its horrible descendant, fanaticism, have long possessed this beautiful earth.

They have filled the earth with violence, drenched it often with human blood, destroyed civilisation and sent whole nations into despair…. The present convention is in itself a vindication of the wonderful doctrine presented in the Gita: ‘Whosoever comes to Me, through whatsoever form, I reach him. All men are struggling through paths which in the end lead to Me.’

– Swami Vivekananda: Here are the most despicable understanding of values that Indians can possibly have: Please donate to help Kerala Hindus. The Christians and Muslims worldwide raising lots of money to help mainly their own people and agenda.

– Rajiv Malhotra (USA). Floods in Kerala are due to tantric and mantric worship. Tsunami was God’s wrath in India for idol worship.

– Evangelist Lazarus Mohan (Tamil Nadu) In a way it is abhorrent to mention in the same breath the names of Vivekananda, the swami of enlightenment, and the latter-day peddlers of religious hatred.

Chicago, where Vivekananda addressed the World Parliament of Religions, was picked as the venue for the World Hindu Congress recently. But Chicago heard this time a different voice that called for a sectarian war lest “the lone lion is destroyed by wild dogs”. This lone lion must be a new contraption because Hinduism can never be destroyed, not even by those who are misusing it from within.

Vivekananda’s short address in Chicago is still remembered, 125 years later, as a historic marker in the march of ideas. At the assembled “parliament” of spiritual leaders from all corners of the world, Vivekananda stood out as a majestic figure—a 30-year-old in saffron a robe with a maharaja-like turban. His opening words, “My sisters and brothers of America”, led to applause that made the speaker pause for a while.

The message of brotherhood and universal tolerance he conveyed in the next few minutes made him the star of Chicago. It was the first time the West heard a credible Indian voice from India, and it helped demolish the British-projected view of a benighted India lost in primitive superstitions.

Vivekananda’s India, too, appears to be lost. These are days when, for every genuine holy man, there are a dozen fakes. Some flourish with ashrams spread across vast acreages. Some start business empires that conquer everything they set their sights on. Some are in jail. The religious exploiters come in many robes. Madrasas are rife with scandals of child abuse while convents are exploding with charges of nuns being used for the pleasure of priests. Perhaps for the first time in the history of the church in India, nuns have come out in the open protesting against the sexual escapades of a bishop.

Under our prevailing criminal law, a formal charge by a woman is enough to take the accused into custody for interrogation. But this bishop has proved to be special. Forces stronger than God are protecting him.When Vivekananda said, “I am proud to be a Hindu”, he must have had in mind the Hinduism that respected all. The greatness of Hinduism—and the uniqueness of it—is that you can reject all the gods in the Hindu pantheon and still be a Hindu. But the corollary is that you can worship all the gods in the pantheon and still be not a Hindu. The politicians who divide people on religious grounds are not helping their religion. They are just exploiters.

A saint who said “we accept all religions as true” is being appropriated by a party that suppresses minorities for political gains. Vivekananda was an original liberal. He promoted the cause of modern education and modern science. The casteism in Kerala provoked him to describe that state as a lunatic asylum. How would he describe the states where people lynch people in the name of religion? How would he describe Raja Singh Lodh, BJP MLA in Telangana, who said, “Till the cow is accorded the status of Rashtra Mata, killings for gau raksha will continue”? Swami Vivekananda was blessed that he lived in another, civilised, India.

Like our page https://www.facebook.com/MalayalamDailyNews/ and get latest news update from USA, India and around the world. Stay updated with latest News in Malayalam, English and Hindi.

Print This Post Print This Post
To toggle between English & Malayalam Press CTRL+g

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read More

Scroll to top